Sunday, November 15, 2026

The Historicity of Jesus...and Paul

My recent thoughts on the historicity of Jesus have wandered all around much as the Biblical Hebrews...

Until recently, I was willing to believe there was a historical Galilee born itinerant preacher, who gained some following and was ultimately crucified, even if all the miracles and even the resurrection were removed from the story.

Then I became convinced the whole story was a myth, created either by "the Apostle Paul" or even by "James the Brother of Jesus," as at least seven of the key stories about Jesus, starting with the Slaughter of the Innocents, could not have happened without being otherwise known to contemporary non-Christian writers and historians, which they are not (and in fact Jesus does not appear in any contemporary writings that we can confirm, except a couple of brief mentions in the work of Josephus around 90 CE).

I got into a multipart argument with Grok about this today.  Grok insisted that a historical Jesus was accepted by the mainstream "historical consensus."  Well, as you might imagine, I don't give a damned about a "historical consensus," especially within the West which has virtually been defined by Christianity since 325 CE.

When I claimed that Paul invented the story of Jesus in 62 CE (which is only a minor claim relative to the general historicity of Jesus) Grok responded that the historical consensus was that Paul's letter to the Galatians is believed to have been written 50-60 CE, and that Jesus existence is also established by the Acts of the Apostles and Josephus.

Well, well, the earliest known copy of the Paul's letter to the Galatians is 175-225 CE, the Acts of the Apostles is historically dated to around 100 CE (with the earliest known copies dating to second or third centuries), and Josephus is as reliable as heck.

But now, it appears there is yet another thing.  It is even less well established that Paul existed.  Unlike Jesus, who gets a couple of brief mentions in Josephus, that do not at least appear to be interpolations (though interpolated elements may have been added to them) Paul gets no mention at all.  Outside of Christian writings, Paul gets no mention either in Graeco-Roman history OR in Jewish histories.  And someone who did even of the fraction of the things he is said to have done, should have at least gotten some mention.  There's no evidence even that early Christian churches received the letters he supposedly wrote.

https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateAChristian/comments/flmac/paul_did_not_exist/

At this point, I throw up my hands.  I don't know.  And I'm not sure how much it matters, since even if there was a historical Jesus and a historical Paul, the religiously significant things attributed to them could not have happened anyway.


Saturday, November 14, 2026

Official Write-Ins are Now Counted

 I have found the official Texas Secretary of State report on the November 2026 Election Results, and it shows the vote counts for all official candidates, including Official Write-Ins.  There were several Official Write-Ins for US Senator from Texas.

https://electionresults.sos.state.tx.us/results.html

The Official Write-Ins for US Senator got between 1925 and 186 votes.  The Libertarian Ted Brown who was actually listed on the ballot got 191,000 votes.  The difference between Democrat Talerico and Republican Patrick was over a million votes.

Anyone can become an Official Write-In for US Senator in Texas by paying a $5000 fee, or collecting 5000 signatures.  Other offices mostly required lesser amounts and/or lesser signatures. 

This is important in my book because any vote that gets counted is not a wasted vote.  Candidates and potential candidates in future elections may make decisions on that if the numbers are large enough.  It's only pointless to vote for a candidate who is either not listed or not an Official Write-In.

https://www.sos.state.tx.us/elections/candidates/guide/2026/writein2026.shtml

To get on the ballot as a listed candidate, you must be selected by one of 4 parties recognized by Texas: Democratic, Republican, Green, or Libertarian.  Those parties are required to have "conventions" at multiple levels to select candidates.  If you wish to run as the candidate for these parties, you have to apply to the county chair and win selection by the convention(s).  Then there is also the fee and/or signature requirements which are similar or identical to those required for Write-In candidates.

https://www.sos.state.tx.us/elections/candidates/guide/2026/lib-green-nom2026.shtml

To establish a new state recognized political party requires electing certain officers, and producing a set of party rules that meet Texas requirements  It requires having party conventions at multiple levels.  And it requires convention participation of at least 1% of the vote count in the preceding election for Governor, for 2022 that was 81,030.

https://www.sos.state.tx.us/elections/candidates/guide/2026/starting-a-party.shtml


Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Did Zionists lobby against rescuing Jews from the Holocaust ?

A standard part of the Zionist narrative is that during the Holocaust, other nations refused Jewish refugees so Palestine (which later became Israel) was their only hope.

The truth is that Zionists themselves lobbied against the rescue of Jews to destinations other than Palestine.  Exactly how far this went* requires a careful examination of history that has largely been buried and forgotten.  And at least once, Zionists refused to rescue some Jews (elderly and sickly) even to Palestine on the grounds that they were not suitable for building the new hoped for state.

(*We might want to know, for example, if Jewish lives that could have been saved somewhere were lost because of the insistence by Zionists that rescued Jews go to Palestine in preference to all other destinations.  And if so, how many, when, and where.)

One of the more complete examinations of this topic is in Tony Greenstein's excellent and essential book, Zionism During the Holocaust, especially in Chapter 12 entitled "Refugeeism and the Obstruction of Rescue."  The first edition hardcover I have is now out of print but Tony will send an electronic copy if you make a donation to a Palestinian charity for children he supports.  A second edition is being created.

Many of the other chapters are also relevant to these questions.  I confess I am a very slow reader of books and have not digested much yet from this one.  I have read many of Tony's blog posts on the topic, but have trouble reconstructing them in arguments with others (or my own blog posts).  I can state that the history damns Zionists as I have stated, but I cannot answer the "exactly how far this went" questions except in broad outlines.

For example, Zionists made a deal with the Nazis for the rescue of a small number of Zionist elites in Germany at the cost of not revealing the Holocaust to other Jews who might have resisted more or escaped from it.

Zionists rhetorically defended such acts, saying that it was more important to build a state for some Jews than to rescue all the Jews to other locations.

When it was most critical during the Holocaust, Zionists thwarted efforts by US Jews to rescue European Jews to the USA on the grounds that they were better sent to Israel.  Specifically they fought Bergson who was lobbying for the creation of a War Refugee Board (WRB) to rescue Jews to USA, overcoming immigration restrictions.  Later the WRB was created and USA became the second most popular destination for Holocaust survivors after Palestine/Israel.  Then Zionists claimed they had been for it all along.

Zionists similarly (or worse) lobbied against the emigration of European Jews to the UK during the Holocaust.

A good summary of some of Greenstein's key findings is here:

https://electronicintifada.net/content/how-zionism-helped-nazis-perpetrate-holocaust/37326

Another very long examination of this issue is here:

https://www.palestineremembered.com/Articles/General-2/Story38175.html



The NYC Trifecta

 It now looks like the most 3 powerful people in the US government next year, Trump, Schumer, and Jeffries, will all be from New York City.

All the members of the Trifecta are heavily backed by AIPAC, and many speculate, mob money as well.  Speaking of which, Schumer and Trump hung out together at Studio 54 to celebrate mob lawyer Roy Cohn's birthday in 1979 (photos available online) and probably other years as well.  Roy Cohn was a lifelong registered Democrat.  Donald Trump played both sides of the aisle for most of his life, donating to Carter while he was still a registered Republican for example, and he switched his registration many times.

With a crew like the Trifecta, we can expect nothing related to wars for Israel will change for the better, and probably little other change for the better can be expected too.

An early illustration is now given by the first attempt to impeach Hegseth, the most vicious and incompetent "Secretary of War" ever.  The resolution was proposed by Thomas Massie, an antiwar Republican, but nearly all Republicans voted against it.  The measure lost by 7 votes, but 11 Democrats couldn't be bothered to vote for it, including heavily AIPAC backed Nancy Pelosi and Haley Stevens.  Behind the scenes, the future Speaker-to-be Jeffries was supposed to be lining up Democratic Party votes, but "failed" with a cast of self-selected 'Rotating Villans.'

AOC, who has famously refused to consider anyone but Jeffries for speaker (and even now given a condescending white board talk for constituents explaining what the speaker does, and why Jeffries is so crucial for that role), is also from NYC.  Many self described progressive Democrats, and even (I'm sad to say) many chapters of DSA (including my own local one) have already endorsed AOC for our next President.   (I suppose we can hardly hope for anyone better, but it still seems premature to me.  Premature endorsements of people like AOC anger people who are trying to be consistent about supporting Palestine.  AOC has not been consistent, waffling over the issue of supposedly "defensive" weapons for Israel.  DSA and the like should hold off their endorsements as leverage to get guarantees, including guarantees that they will not support weapons for Israel and will not endorse anyone who does.).

Jeffries may be effective as anyone for Speaker but the question is what is he being effective about?  An Israel-firsters like Jeffries can be expected to be most effective about supporting military aid and wars for Israel above everything else.  And that's exactly what we don't need.

Self-styled Democratic Party champions have said the Speaker choice needs to be left to Congress, it's none of the business of other US citizens.  We couldn't possibly know enough, etc.

Jeffries has said that "punishing" the Trump administration is not on his agenda, he be believes that what Americans have demanded in the 2028 elections is that he fix the affordability crisis.  I don't even have to consult my magic 8 ball to predict how well that is going to go, especially if all the wars and aid to Israel continue.  Choosing such an unattainable goal as the only goal, especially while not addressing the root causes, means that nothing positive will get done at all, not even symbolically.

The only way to restore affordability, in fact the only way to prevent collapse of the western economies, is to make a deal with Iran that Israel will hate, and a deal with Russia that Zelensky will hate.  The most powerful Democrats (among others) are opposed to these ends.

Perhaps I should stop worrying and learn to love Israel and Zelensky, because no forces better than their insatiability can collapse the western empire more quickly.  And along with it, the Republican and Democratic Party duopoly in the US.


Saturday, November 7, 2026

Geese's critique of PSL

https://geesemag.com/articles/psls-top-propagandist-resigns-publishes-tell-all

Interesting, and it covers a lot of ground including ACP and the Red Star Caucus within DSA.  It gives a good definition of the word “tendency” I’ve seen used a lot.  But I wouldn’t take it too seriously.  The basic criticism is what we already know.  PSL is more like a Leninist cult* than an open membership organization.  As such, it will attempt to, and in fact it must, quash internal “rebellions” that seek to transform it into something else.  And PSL is one among many following that approach, probably the best, way better than RCP or ACP or anything else I can think of that still exists in USA.

ISO** was similar in reach but no longer exists, they were in some ways similar to PSL (anti-Popular Frontist, for one thing) but ISO was Trotskyist, whereas PSL is Leninist--which is much much better.  Trotskyists and Trotskyites serve Imperialists by critiquing all their foes, really (or formerly) existing 'Communist' countries such as USSR, Cuba, Vietnam, and China.  True communists recognize all resistance to Empire as a good thing, even republican theocracies such as Iran and anti-imperialist capitalist countries such as the Russian Federation.  True communists, Marxist Leninists, are one with the concept of Popular Front, and will even work with capitalist parties like the Democratic Party when it is useful to do so.  PSL follows a "Marxism And Leninism" line which eschews Popular Frontism in principle, though not always in practice.

When you become an open membership organization, what you get is something like DSA, which is hardly revolutionary at all, often accused of being a Democratic Party shill for the left.  BTW, I'm a member of DSA because it's easy to be one, and though I don't always agree with their collective judgements, I think they are useful too.  One thing about DSA is they haven't yet established a "thought police," you can believe anything you want and still be a member, they don't even pretend to be Democratic Centralist, in fact their founder fundamentally opposed that idea.

PSL’s thesis, that USA is not ready for revolution, is basically correct.  Geese Review is not doing anything better, in fact they’re not even on the map.  It’s nearly impossible to find out anything about them they’re so tiny.  They’re just flame throwers, disparaging everyone else, even though they have little to offer.  So I wouldn’t worry about their critique, especially as I’m not tithing to PSL as a "member" anyway.  I'm just an ally who attends their protests and other events, sometimes chipping in a few bucks to help.  When and if Geese ever  assembles an organization as large as PSL, and does something more than just flame throwing in the circular firing squad of the left, I'll be their ally too.

Here's Smolarek's resignation letter:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vRIyGuCR41exdzbcZSf8BZC73zyY21Wq2Hpjii19ZnVc5AiZZBgJzKkkPrKZlZ7wtINcPdOGwZv-bga/pub

I wish Smolarek the best of luck.  If he creates a new organization where there's a local chapter where I can attend meetings, I will.  I won't swear off going to PSL meetings until I have a better choice, and maybe not even then, if I have time for both, etc.

Organizing is tough shit.  I expect petty tyrants to be at the top.  That doesn't make me not want to participate.  OTOH, people close to the top, I can imagine how they can feel too.  Not just burned out enough to leave but pissed off enough to write angry open resignation letters.  But I'm not going to take any of it too seriously, short of actual criminal actions.

Meanwhile, I also expect that it will usually be denied that there are petty tyrants at the top.  Organizations will describe themselves as "democratic" and "open."  I won't be the least surprised if I find out these things are not true.  I would be more surprised if they were true.

*Any small Leninist organization will seem like a cult.  Lenin in practice (if not rhetoric) required loyalty more than mass membership.  That doesn't mean such organizations are useless.  It is important to have one or more of those.  In addition, Class Consciousness raising, as I've pointed out before, is the thing and just about the only thing at this point.  PSL is correct about this, even seeming to echo my points in a recent post. But I'd recommend not voting for any "party" that isn't large enough or organized enough to get on the ballot.  I don't do write-ins anymore, they just don't get counted.  When you can, vote for a party like The Green Party which has very good positions and often IS on the ballot.  Vote for the best party on the ballot, regardless of whether people believe they can win, just to show your support for that POV.  And don't take any flame throwing from circular firing squads seriously.

**ISO was brought down by internal sex scandals at the top.  What PSL is being accused of is trivial by comparison.  I always felt that if I got involved with ISO enough, I'd get laid too, and I sometimes wish I had.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

"Antisemitism"

"Antisemitism" is a wrongly used and applied word, so I will try to avoid using it.  The word effectively erases other Semites, which include "Arabs": Palestinians, Lebanese, etc.

The correct word is 'Anti-Jewish' which can be followed by 'racism,' 'bigotry,' 'hatred', etc.  That would be against "Jews" which is itself a problematic word, as I shall show below, but can be taken determined by identification (people who identify themselves (individually or by collective authority) as "Jews").

Generally, all forms of general racism, bigotry, and hatred are bad things.  However, it is more important that people be able to think and speak freely than to avoid all such bad things.  Racism, bigotry, and hatred become actionable when they are used in official contexts (such as official statements by a government official), or lead to further crimes imminently, such as racial discrimination or violence.

Often confounded with anti-Jewish racism are anti-Judaism and anti-Zionism.  Neither are "races."

Anti-Judaism is criticism of the set of religious traditions known as Judaism.  Criticizing a religious tradition is fair game, as most religious traditions themselves criticize other religious traditions.  However, once again, civil rights apply to people regardless of religion and so must be avoided in official statements by government officials, discrimination, or violence.

Anti-Zionism is criticism of the geopolitical project known as Zionism, which maintains that (1) the Jews are a people (they are not, see below), (2) that all peoples deserve sovereignty of a particular geographical area (they do not, they deserve to co-exist with other people there), and (3) to achieve those ends, it is acceptable to have an apartheid state, ethnic cleansing, or genocide of others.

"Jews" is not a word used to describe a distinct or unusual ancestry.  Historically it was used to describe 'people who follow Judaism' and that is still, really, the best definition, as nothing else fits.  That is how I will use the word 'Jews.'

Since its inception (for which the best evidence appears to be around 300 BCE, as that is when the earliest known copies of the Torah are found) Judaism has been and still is a proselytizing religion.  Anyone can convert to Judaism so long as they are accepted as such into a Jewish congregation (who have may have differing rules regarding such acceptance, though it typically requires circumcision for males, and renunciation of other "gods" including especially Jesus Christ).  Equally important, anyone can covert out of Judaism, as in fact many Jewish descendants have done all along the history of Judaism.

In ancient history, Jews and their predecesssor proto-Jews (such as Hebrews) spread around the world for both voluntary (foreign opportunities) and involuntary (being taken as hostages or slaves) reasons.  Voluntary relocations vastly exceeded the involuntary, starting from when Jews took over the international Phoenician trade networks after the defeat and collapse of the Phoenician empire.  In other parts of the world, especially in Africa and Eastern Europe, they converted many others into Judaism, especially through marriage, since others needed to convert to Judaism to marry a Jew who wished to remain Jewish.  By the beginning of the first millennium of the Common Era, more Jews lived outside of greater Judea than within.  (And Greater Judea itself, then known as the Roman Province of Judea, was a vast expansion of the original Judea--a small region surrounding Jerusalem-- through conquests by the Hasmonean Kingdom which were followed by mass conversions to Judaism, making them all Jews by that means, though it may not have stuck for long, as many within both proper Judea and Greater Judea later converted to other religions, especially Christianity and Islam.)

Nowadays Zionist Jews like to feign or impute Greater Judean indigeneity in the claim that they have a unique ancestral connection to that region.  But they do not.  There were others who were always there, and there were many Jews there who descendants converted to other religions.  Meanwhile, Jews have been so widely dispersed into other parts of the western world, and intermarried with non-Jews, sometimes but not always continuing to be Jewish, that virtually everyone in the West now has at least some Judean ancestry too.  But the ones who have the greatest Greater Judean ancestry are the people who remained in Greater Judea and simply converted to other religions, including Islam and Christianity.

Meanwhile, the endless attempts of Zionists to label anti-Zionists as "Antisemitic" deserves a word of its own.  That could be Anti-anti-Zionism (AAZ).  AAZ attempts to erase the civil rights of people to criticize any government, or to denounce the terrible actions of Zionists especially in the middle east.  AAZ belongs to the same set of tendencies as fascism.  There is also Anti-Anti-Judaism (AAJ), which attempts to erase the civil rights of people to criticize any religion. 


Wednesday, October 21, 2026

Democrats and James Talerico on the War in Ukraine


Every solid Democrat I know is going ballistic over Trump's lean towards cooperation with Russia and ending War in Ukraine.  Few have gotten so worked up over any issue I've seen before.

My brother-in-law is a strict atheist materialist, believes in no afterlife, and has long been very critical of suicide.  However, the idea of ending support for the War in Ukraine and making peace with Russia has made him suicidal for the first time I know of or can even imagine.

James Talerico, Democratic candidate for US Senate from Texas, says "I believe it is our duty as the world's oldest democracy to defend Ukraine from Russian aggression."

One thing I might agree about is that this is an important issue, and possibly the single most important issue of our time.  We are at the point where Ukraine can only win with a massive attack on Russia, which Russia would surely reciprocate as it has been doing, then with European powers adding their weight, it would lead to World War 3 and nuclear annihilation for all.

Ted Brown, the Libertarian candidate for US Senator from Texas, rarely seems to address Ukraine directly.  But he says we should withdraw from NATO, withdraw from all 800+ foreign bases, end [military] aid to all middle eastern countries, cancel all sanctions and tariffs, and that only Congress has the authority to declare war.  Long ago, before the war started, he once said US should not defend Ukraine.  I've been unable to find any more recent comment.

There is no Green Party or Socialist candidate in the race for US Senator from Texas.

Ivan Katchanovski, a serious Ukrainian born scholar I've followed for years, has written a book on the origins of the War in Ukraine, which can be downloaded for free from Springer:

https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-98724-3?source=shoppingads&locale=en-it&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=19143447078&gbraid=0AAAAADu685P_qBsNH3GsYdO8t1Kss944x&gclid=CjwKCAiAnoXNBhAZEiwAnItcG-0ExlX7-OufQhkzCXbeVX02BBznZ0Dm7UweTvPpKoHca6xMo90A7hoCHUgQAvD_BwE

One of my favorite reporters, Aron Mate, has written a book on the War in Ukraine.  While critical of Putin's invasion of Ukraine, he insists this war was provoked by US and is a proxy war between US and Russia which many in US are pressing Ukraine to fight "to the last Ukrainian."

https://www.amazon.com/Their-Blood-Our-Bullets-US-Russia/dp/1682194590

Iulia Mendel, former press secretary to Zelensky, says this war is going very badly for Ukraine and must be settled now.

I'm pretty sure I have the same views on this war as former Swiss intelligence officer Jacques Baud, who has made this interview I haven't had time to watch:

https://rumble.com/v5fjhrh-jacques-baud-nato-threatened-russia-decades-before-2022.html

Craig Murray, a former diplomat, is also on that page, as is political science professor Glenn Diesen.  Actually there's a very long list of people qualified by education and/or experience who argue that the West provoked the War in Ukraine as a proxy war to cripple, disadvantage, or break up Russia, and that it is now going very badly and must be ended soon for the benefit of all.  This is not just "Russian Propaganda," in fact it is the reverse view which represents "Western Propaganda" amplified by western politicians and media.

Democrats seem to be stuck on the "to the last Ukrainian" page.  Of course, thanks to US propaganda, most magnified on their favorite network MSNOW,  they believe Russia is losing badly and don't think this is a problem.

If I were to follow the principles I laid out in an earlier post entitled "#1 and #1", it would seem I must vote for Ted Brown, despite my lack of agreement with him on other issues.

https://verydeepleft.blogspot.com/2026/08/voting-for-system-change.html

Every time I hear a Democrat ranting about this issue, it makes me feel like that is even more necessary.

Jeffrey Sachs presents a sensible peace proposal.

https://consortiumnews.com/2026/10/21/jeffrey-sachs-a-framework-for-peace-in-ukraine/

But Democrats are beyond sense at this point, having talked themselves in a furious Russophobia since 2016 when they blamed their lost election on Russia rather than themselves (a completely false narrative because Russian influence was minimal).  Since then, endless falsely reported events and false flag ops have become part of the Democratic Party canon so they can't see Russia as anything but pure evil.  In reality, Russia has only been reacting, conservatively at best, to endless western provocations that barely get reported and even then falsely debunked as "Russian Propaganda."  I'd say the Democratic Party is just as beyond hope as the Republican Party at this time.  And with regards to what could be the most important issue of all, the War in Ukraine, possibly more so.

Sunday, October 18, 2026

The meaning of the Jewish law against Idolatry

 Before I even read it in a tweet by Voice of Rabbis (anti-Zionist), I thought it to myself.  Zionism is an idolatry.  It's worship of state of above God.  It's disobedience to fundamental las against murder, theft, and false witness in the favor of a state of genocide applied to non-jews who have just as much claim, if not more to all of historic Palestine defined as From the River to the Sea.  As well as the rules of Hospitality and Tikkun Olam.

It's breaking the Three Oaths of the Talmud, against creating a state and mass resettling in the Holy Land.  Even when the Messiah comes, it means the Messiah rules the world from Jerusalem, which was hoped to be a world mostly full of Jews, not that all Jews go to Jerusalem.  Not waiting for God to do what God has insisted you wait for him to do is the highest form of disrespect.

I see Neturei Karta is correct in this fundamentalist reading, and consistent with most rabbis of 100 years ago and virtually all of 130 years ago.

But among these, the worst accusation in the Jewish laws is Idolotry, so that is the most serious offense in the context of Judaism.

But in what I'm going to say now, this accusation that something is idolatrous is fundamentally anti social.

It stems from monotheism, though possibly you could have a universalistic monotheism that doesn't recognize such a crime as idolatry as such.  To be consistent, it would also have to not recognize heresy.  It would be fully accepting of syncreetism, not explicity anti other.  So what if other people are worshipping Ba'al?  What matters, is are they obeying all the other laws.  None of the Abrahamic religions is like this, but others, like Taoism, are.  Polytheistic religions tend naturally to accept others and simply add their new gods to their own.

So the rot of fascism and all forms of socio political domination like current neoliberal imperialism goes back to one thing:  monotheism.

In order to accept others, we must accept that they see God(s) differently, unless we are indending to create a subgroup which separates us from all others.

The only solution for a global religion is to adopt such a view.

Then, I suppose, I couldn't insist that Zionists quit being idolatrous.  But I could still demand that Zionists quit breaking all the other laws.

https://www.reddit.com/r/taoism/comments/nh7ka1/has_anyone_attempted_to_reconcile_monotheism_with/

https://arthurmag.com/2007/12/06/the-advantages-of-polytheism/

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

A Revolution in Consciousness

 Humanity has never been more at a crossroads than it is today.  We are threatened with giga catastrophes including possible extinction largely at our own hands because of ecological disasters of our own making, including global heating, civilizational if not biological extinction from global nuclear war, and a dismal future of mass slavery resulting from rising fascism.

It is often tempting to believe that the only solution is through violent seizure of the powers that be in society.

In the USA and Europe, I believe this is at best premature.  The first revolution that has to occur is a revolution in consciousness, what Marxists often call Class Consciousness.

Class consciousness has been virtually engineered out of existence by the capitalist mass media and other sources of propaganda.

But it was also at least party suppressed by New Deal programs and agencies in the USA and social democracy in Europe.  Now that those have been replaced by harsh Neoliberalism, which has also kept wages low compared to productivity, there is increasing justified anger at the ruling class and economic system.

(The excess productivity has gone to the excessive wealth of the oligarchs along with their outsized spending and influence, and destructive "investments" in endless war and Artificial Idiocy, rather than into useful work with a payback like a virtually complete conversion to a renewable energy system.  And not to worker needs like sensible private housing, free healthcare, and free education.)

Thus the conditions are also ripe for the re-emergence, hopefully bigger this time, of Class Consciousness.

People need to understand these things:

1) Humanity and the planet cannot sustain the drive for endless growth in profits of financial capitalism, which is the essence of modern Imperialism also.  The drive for endless growth in profits is the basic cause of all the largest problems of humanity at this time.  We must wrest control of capitalist finance and its friends in government to begin to solve those problems.

2) The People's Republic of China (RPC) is the one government which stands out in having adopted the best working form of socialism at this time, and this largely consists of controlling finance and other leading Commanding Heights (Lenin's term) of the economy.  It does not abolish ownership or unequal wealth.  More Chinese are homeowners than in the USA.  It could be better, and perhaps if more equal too, but it has been delivering the greatest growth in satisfying human needs in any country recently thanks to the "Communist" or "Socialist" system it has.  All other governments would be best served by moving to a similar system.

It is primary duty not to organize political showdowns like General Strikes now but to first raise the level of Class Consciousness that would sustain them, which just isn't there yet.

Now, to some degree, to a great degree, success has to come from truly mass class consciousness.  When it is predictably blocked by the capitalist ruling class and blocked using violence, we must be able to respond to that.  So I am not saying that violence is not ever called for, but we are no where near that point in Western countries in 2026.

And meanwhile the purpose of organizing activities, like the very limited protests we have today, is to help raise class consciousness, not violently overthrow the state.


Sunday, October 4, 2026

The Hebrew Myth Explained

According to the Torah itself, the story of the Hebrews was that they were NOT indigenous.   The Hebrews were outsiders, the word itself means "wanderers." 

Note, there is no actual evidence for most of this, but this is the foundational myth of Judaism which Jews themselves reference and largely believe in as proof of their prior residency in Palestine.  The best evidence is that the Abraham myth was cooked up around 300 BCE, and the Israelites were simply a sect that developed among Canaanites and therefore the Israelite descendants, if thats what the Jews actually are (and most are at best highly mixed with others especially Europeans), have no exclusive ancestral claim to Palestine, only a partial and diluted one.  And it should be added that an ancient ancestral claim isn't worth a cup of coffee from present owners, especially a diluted one shared with millions of others.  So either by myth or by best available historical evidence, the Zionist Entity represents a murderous illegal invasion, theft, and occupation of Palestine, breaking many if not most of the laws of Judaism itself.

I explored the actual historical evidence vs the myths of Judaism in a previous post:

https://verydeepleft.blogspot.com/2026/09/judaism-is-plagiarism.html

But even the myths say that the Jews were not the only descendants of Abraham either.  I hold that virtually everyone in the west has at least some Judean descent because of the many generations that have passed and the fact that the Judeans in diaspora intermarried more with white European elites than any other group.

Copied from Facebook written by Rashid Siddique

The Hebrews … the outsiders
If we trace the story as even the Hebrew Bible itself tells it, it becomes clear:
• Abraham was from Ur (Mesopotamia, today Iraq). His homeland was not Canaan, not “Israel,” but ancient Sumer.
• Isaac and Jacob — they only lived in Canaan temporarily. Altogether, that “stay” was less than a century. That hardly makes them native to the land.
• Jacob’s sons (the so-called “tribes of Israel”) were not born in Canaan at all — most of them were born in Mesopotamia, and later lived in Egypt.
• The whole “Israelite people” only entered Canaan from Egypt — meaning by their own book, they were outsiders, migrants, or if we put it bluntly: invaders.
So if someone shouts today: “We are indigenous to the land of Israel!” — even their own Torah disagrees. The roots are Mesopotamian and Egyptian. Canaan was someone else’s land.
The word “Hebrew” (Ivri / Ê¿Apiru / Habiru) itself didn’t mean “chosen people” or “indigenous tribe” — it literally meant outsiders, wanderers, stateless people.
The Canaanites (and Egyptians too) used the term to describe roaming groups who came from outside the land. In other words, the name itself already admits: “We weren’t from here.”
Throughout history, nearly every group in the region—Ancient Egyptians, Canaanites, Philistines, Babylonians, Persians, Greeks, Romans, Arabs, Crusaders, Ottomans, British, Palestinians, and others—has at some point regarded the Hebrews as invaders or occupiers.
All names of the cities and places in Palestine are older than to be Hebrew words In Palestine all cities and places have Canaanite names and were built by the Canaanites; even long time before an Abraham and his gang fled there from Ur, in today Iraq.
The Hebrew slaves from Egypt never built any cities in the land of Canaan and the Philstines - the Hebrew tribes and thievs stole every thing from the Canaanites, even their language ...
"The Canaanites were first.
And when we speak of "Palestinians" or of the
"Arab" population, we bear in mind their Canaanite origin." -
"The Land of Canaan" by llene Beatty
Major urban centers were not built by Hebrews; they settled the hill country villages. 
Archaeological evidence shows typical Hebrew settlements were small, walled villages, often built on previously unoccupied sites.
There is no evidence that the Hebrews founded major coastal cities or lowland Canaanite cities.
Archaeology shows Hebrews mostly settled in previously lightly populated hill country rather than building large new cities.
Even the Bible itself confirms it.
As it says in Joshua 24:13:
“I gave you a land on which you had NOT labored and cities you had NOT built, and you live in them; you eat from vineyards and olive trees you did NOT plant.”

Deuteronomy 7:1 further spells out that when Israelites came to the "Promised Land" there were 7 other nations already there:  Hittites, Girgashites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzities, Hivites, and Jebusites.  

Before David took it over (if he even existed and ever did) the city of Jerusalem was already a walled city with a fortified water source built by the Canaanites before and during the Bronze Age and named after the Canaanite god Shalim, god of the dusk (and, by implication, peace...the ultimate irony for a city that has been reconquered 44 times).

No matter how you slice it, either by their own book or known history, the idea that Jews are "the indigenous people" of the modern state of Israel is illiterate and ahistorical ignorance, stupidity and madness used to justify a genocidal modern colonization only made possible by UK and US and European imperialism. 

Wednesday, September 30, 2026

"Democracy" promotion

 USAID backed Internews in Ukraine in 2001 was proping up 203 TV stations and 126 radio stations and training 1900 "journalists."

https://x.com/ricwe123/status/2105243331340943661

Staged Antisemitic Attacks

 Here is a list of alleged antisemitic attacks staged by Jewish Zionists themselves since 2004:

https://x.com/_ZachFoster/status/2105305474006409408

In one of the most recent incidents, a Jewish lady and her daughter were caught on security cameras vandalizing their own apartment building with swastikas which they had been complaining about for months.  In one of the more destructive ones, a Jewish man in Toronto Canada set his own synagogue on fire.  In one of the more amusing ones, a Jewish student group plastered campus with antisemitic stickers claiming to be from Palestinian supporters but actually commissioned by the Jewish student group themselves.

Many incidents like these go back to the Baghdad temple bombings in 1950-51 if not earlier.

Staged attacks are clearly illegal, immoral, and forbidden by the basic laws of Judaism including the one against bearing false witness.

Zionism is a perversion and negation of Judaism.  If there were the jealous God envisioned by Judaism, I would have thought He would have stopped it by now, as was said to have happened many times to Hebrews in the Torah.  Of course, Zionist idolatry of statehood, coveting the lands and homes of Palestinians, and murderous violence to get it, in clear violation of many of the laws of Judaism, had even preceded the Holocaust, so there is that.  But it didn't really get rolling like today until after the Holocaust, and God seems to have been relatively reserved after that, so reserved that Zionists have felt compelled to stage attacks on themselves.


Sunday, September 27, 2026

Judaism is Plagiarism

Antoun Ananias makes the case for Judaism almost entirely being copied from other religions, with the exception of Isaiah, which was a supernatural revenge fantasy against the many conquerors and overlords of Judea,  and that Isaiah itself was written by several authors about 100 BCE.  The Hebrews were a minor tribal sect that emerged in Judea circa 1000 BCE and lasted about 200 years having Chieftains, not Kings, and about whose religion we have no evidence at all.  He concludes that Judaism and Christianity are competing irrationalist cults both following the narrative from Isaiah, [one saying the Messiah has come once and will come again later, and the other saying the Messiah hasn't come at all yet] and the world would and will eventually be better off without either.  If it hadn't been for Christianity's success is becoming a world religion, Judaism and all of its fantastical claims about what happened during the First Temple period--which lack any evidence in archeology--would have been long ago forgotten.  Even at the start of the Hasmonean Kingdom, whose midpoint was when Isaiah was written according to Antoun Ananias, Judea proper was a rather small region surrounding Jerusalem and the original much smaller Second Temple ,which was later greatly expanded by the Roman vassal Herod the Great, whose father was an Idumean--a descendant of the Edomites to the southeast of Judea and whose land was one of many territories conquered by the Hasmonians. 



The Hasmonean Kingdom lasted 103 years until it was conquered, this time by the Romans. Commenters state that this was all common knowledge 50 years ago and seems to have been forgotten because of Zionism which attempts to revive the image of a mythical ancient world of Hebrews sprawling across the Levant which never existed.  In fact, I myself first heard these things about 50 years ago, from some guy I met in college (a White history major btw) and I couldn't believe it.

https://medium.com/@antounananias/why-judaism-is-plagiarism-cba5efb0c825

I see that others claim that Isaiah was written starting in the 8th century (by the actual "Prophet Isaiah") and ending in the 5th century.  I have not seen and I doubt there is any physical evidence for this.  In fact, the earliest known copy of the Book of Isaiah is from the Dead Sea Scrolls.  The Dead Sea Scrolls date from 250 to 125 BCE, and it seems like they also have the earliest known copies of the other books in the Torah or Old Testament, except for small fragments of blessings found in earlier writings.  According to legend, the rest of the Torah et all had been passed down verbally before that.

Recently I have been fond of the idea that the Torah was conceived and composed (if not written down) during or immediately after Babylonian captivity and the Persian release, written to create the myths that the Jews being "returned" to Judea would live by as a religious sect (explicitly not a country or nation) occupying the land near the country Egypt which Persia sought to conquer.  They were written so as to be compatible with monotheistic Persian Zoroastrianism, to indicate that the Jews had a glorious civilization long before, but it all had come to a bad end before, and that they must now wait for a Messiah from God to have another such kingdom again.  It also included a myth of Egyptian captivity to make the Jews hate the Egyptians.  It all fits so perfectly with the Persian intent to conquer Egypt, which they did not long after, I figured the Persians inspired or paid for these compositions to provide a faux history for the "returning" Jews to live by.  Though it is also said they were composed in Babylonian captivity to help preserve a nationalist sentiment.

But there is no evidence the books were written even that soon after the events they supposedly describe from 1400-800 BCE including the Egyptian captivity, for which there is no widely accepted evidence, though some claim there is (I found this link in a comment and am discouraged that it is just a video interview of dubious value rather than serious writing):  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SeI2-YPDTXk

If indeed the books of the Torah were actually composed and written from 300-125 BCE which was before, during or immediately before the Hasmonean Kingdom, it seems more like they were intended to glorify the new Judean priestly and warrior class, instill nationalism, and to motivate and justify the forthcoming Hasmonean* conquests, effectively claiming that the ancestors of the Jews had previously ruled over some of these same lands beyond Judea proper in a glorious ancient kingdom promised to them by God (ie, conquered and stolen by them way back then) that they were only seeking to "restore."  But there is no physical evidence at all of any of the conquests as described in the Torah.

*The Hasmonean dynasty was begun by military leaders within the Judean priestly class, the Maccabees, when Judea was a province of the Seleucid Empire--which itself was a spinoff of the earlier Greek empire.  Eventually the Hasmonians secured their sovereign independence, but for only 47 years before the Romans finished defeating and annexing them and other remaining Seleucid fragments.  The Hasmonean empire was hated by many of the peoples it conquered and ruled and was in the midst of a civil war between rival Hasmonean brothers when the Romans defeated them.  The Romans formally replaced the Hasmonean rulers with King Herod, an Idumean, in 37 BCE, though at first they gave the new Roman province which included Hasmonean conquests the name Judeah, now effectively the "greater Judea" that the Hasmoneans had conquered and were barely holding on to.

Antoun gives his better sourced and recounted version of the history of the Pentateuch, Tanakh, and Torah and related events here:

https://medium.com/@antounananias/the-aramaic-gospels-vs-the-fake-gospels-2ac1e9073067

The fact that the previous attempted restoration of the Torah's mythological past under the Hasmonean Kingdom lasted only 103 years (and only 47 years as a sovereign nation) gives some hope regarding the shortness of the continued existence of the current one, which is widely and justifiably hated except by most Ashkenazi "Jews" (who Antoun and others such as Shlomo Sand) claim have no descent from the original Judeans.  

I would characterize Ashkenazi descent from ancient Judeans not as nonexistant but rather as minimal and little more than other Europeans, noting that DNA doesn't actually provide a total record of descent because the original DNA can be almost entirely lost by genetic segregation after a few generations of mixing, and after 2000 years even slight mixing over time results in everyone being related somehow despite a lack of distinctive markers which may have been lost.  My maternal family of Jacobson (Christians) claims descent from Jerusalem through James the Just who was definitely a real historical figure, himself a Judean high priest in Jerusalem assassinated on orders of the highest priest Ananus ben Ananus, which was a critical historical event ultimately leading to the sacking of Jerusalem by the Romans.  As the descendants of James the Just were Jewish Christians, they were likely spared by Rome, as well as allowed a free ticket to the empire, so this bloodline has a higher probability of having been preserved than others from Jerusalem at the time which may have been extinguished through war or slavery.  Since pretty much all Europeans are related going back 2000 years, I've decided there is most likely some truth in our descent from James the Just, but not exclusive to me and my immediate ancestral family but shared by nearly all Europeans now.  That is the way human descent actually works over a large number of generations, and it is on that basis that Ashkenazis are not excluded from Judean descent either even if their descent originated from only a handful of Judean founders mixed with Germans which would not be demonstrable with genetics at this point.

While all Europeans must have some Judean descent, the people with the most ancient Judean descent are the Palestinians and Samaritans of today.  They are close enough related to ancient Judeans that you can indeed usually find many of the distinctive genetic markers in them, despite two millennia of mixing and genetic segregation. 

So Jews have no exclusive claim to Judean ancestry, possibly minimal anyway, and "Jewishness" is a religious ethnicity not so much uniquely connected to Judean ancestry as connected to Judaism, a levantine cult whose foundations were written down between 300 and 100 BCE to create nationalistic fervor and to fuel regional conquests, but maintained and spread ever since by its sometimes antagonistic and sometimes synergistic relationship with the more popular levantine cult of Christianity.

In my youth, I found Judaism much more attractive than Christianity because it did not require me to believe in the Jesus divinity and resurrection story, which I detested having to memorize and recite.  I also often found Jewish people I knew to be more like minded and wanted to be part of their club instead of mine.  Judaism seemed based on largely reasonable behavioral rules, which I had largely imbibed anyway through Christianity, and enjoyable rituals, rather than professed beliefs which seemed fake to me.  I only became disenchanted about converting to Judaism when I learned about the Nakba when I was 13 and none of my Jewish friends could give me an adequate explanation of it.  (Though I didn't dump my Jewish friends because of that, and I continued having mostly Jewish or partly Jewish friends, and having fascinations and sometimes dates with Jewish or partly Jewish girls for the rest of my life.). Now I would not tie Judaism unequivocally to Israeli Apartheid and Genocide, I fully respect Jewish Antizionism and see that as the truest and best form of Judaism (Zionism just skips the Messiah requirement and turns state* worship into an idolatry above and negating all the other rules) but there just doesn't seem to be a good reason for me to be immersed in Judaism anyway anymore as opposed to religions or philosophies simply emphasizing care, love. and respect for others, like humanism, Freethinking, and Unitarian Universalism.  Such religions and philosophies can be quite clear about what religious traditions they are quoting from, and can freely pick and choose the best from all of them, and avoid the inhuman and inhumane parts, like Samuel's call for genociding the Amalek and their animals too, the very model of what Israeli Zionists are doing today.  (BTW, the genocide of Amalek never actually happened, but the genocide of Palestinians and the killing of their animals and trees today is very real and disgusting.)

*Orthodox anti-Zionist Jews say that even when the Messiah comes, even that doesn't mean all the Jews flock to and establish another state in Judea.  It simply means that God re-establishes His presence in Jerusalem, then ruling the entire world with goodness which is available to everyone.  I would add that Judaism is supposed to be a proselytizing religion (and once was far more so than today), just like Christianity (which has the same roots), so that by the time the Messiah comes most of the world is supposed to be Jewish anyway making a safe haven for Jews in Judea both unnecessary and an impossibility.  Meanwhile, Jews are supposed to be "healing" the entire world as well as converting everyone who can be converted to Judaism in preparation, and with the added belief that the coming of the Messiah will lead even more to adopt Judaism, so ultimately including almost everyone.  Zionism is the attempt to escape from the rest of the world, a negation of the basic concept in this and other ways.

*****

Ron Unz introduces us to minimalist Copenhagen School of Biblical minimalism, named after the Copenhagen International Seminar hosted by the University of Copenhagen.  Co-founder Thomas Thompson wrote The Historicity of the Patriarchal Narratives: The quest for the Historical Abraham -- a quest that ends nowhere since according to Thompson the stories of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are complete fabrications of the Hellenistic period.  The following year John Van Seters wrote Abraham in History and Tradition added to a paradigm shift which was at first fiercely resisted by the old guard of biblical scholarship but progressively gained wide acceptance among historians.  These authors and their fellows were of course accused of antisemitism by Israeli scholars and smeared in ways that are provably untrue because Minimalists are not only saying that the Bible contains very little real history, they also expose the deliberate deception of its special claim to antiquity.  The Book didn't actually exist until its real authors could read from 200,000 books (scrolls) in the Museum of Alexandria around 300 BCE, and could copy from and elaborate upon previous religious, philosophical, and legal traditions.  Russell Gmirkin excelled in this type of criticism, he showed better than others how The Bible had to have been created this way, and how the story of the Tower of Babel used descriptions of Babylon written by Berossus, but turned them on their head as as Berossus was praising Babylon and the Bible condemns it.  He shows how the story of the 70 translators itself stemmed from a fake letter, attributed to Greek philosopher Aristeas but actually written by a Jew, praising the ancient wisdom of the Jews, quoted by Flavius Josephus.  Josephus believed that letter and turned the actual history around, claiming that Plato "imitated" Moses.

https://www.unz.com/article/the-hellenistic-origin-of-the-torah/

In an earlier book, Gmirkin demonstrates the scholarly method for dating the Hebrew bible by establishing a terminus ante quem (latest possible date) and terminus a quo (earliest possible date).  One termina a quo is provided by the Elephantine papyri written around 400 BCE in upper Egypt by intensely religious Jewish colonists who seem to know nothing of the laws or stories in the Torah, yet they fully recognized Jerusalem's central authority.  Then Gmirkin pushes the date even later by showing the dependence of the Torah on two books written in Greek between 285 and 287 BCE, namely the history of Bablylon written by Berossus, and a history of Egypt written by Manetho rather than the claimed oral or cuneform sources.

Berossus was a priest at the Temple of Bel-Marduk which the story of the Tower of Babel appears to be inspired by.  One would think that a tradition obsessed with monotheism would consider monolingualism a blessing, but the Torah authors condemnation shows that they are not truly monotheist but a monolatrist cult of the jealous god of Israel who hates Babylon.


What Actually Happened on October 7

Quoting Tony Hanania about October 7

https://x.com/AntounAnanias/status/2104272468345000105


 I was there on Oct 7th and could see clear as day what actually happened. I have posted extensively in the Arabic media on this. 

1. The initial response was entirely unprecedented. There was no resistance to 1000s of Gazans breaching what is normally a dangerous security perimeter just to approach 30 yards away.

2. The response that there was focused not on the breaches but on attacking Nova and that soon petered out.

3. The mass slaughter did not take place until after 2pm, 8 hours after the breakout. Two passes of 14 Apaches destroyed virtually everything on the ground indiscriminately. Any cars backed up were missiled. Anything moving was a target. At the same time the Kibbutzim came under attack from tanks 

There is nothing controversial about my account of what I witnessed as the leaked Apache cockpit footage is absolutely explicit. Oct 7th was an indiscriminate and savage war crime perpetrated principally by Israeli forces.

As for the accusations against Hamas, of which I am not a member, 27 of 27 have been proved false or have absolutely no evidence to back them up !!

Trita Parsi adds that while it appeared that Netanyahu didn't tell Israeli intelligence about his input, nevertheless an intelligence chief removed his daughter from the Nova gathering at 4:45 am, leaving the rest to die.

(My own belief is Netanyahu and key Israeli intelligence knew about the Hamas attack the whole time, in fact they were encouraging it.  They had spies in Hamas, they track Palestinian smart phones, and the border if not far beyond is full of Israeli cameras.  They wanted a big event to justify the following genocide.  It was why Netanyahu was behind some funding for Hamas in the first place, he wanted them to do things to justify harsh responses.  It's possible Netanyahu didn't realize how bad this would get, but I wouldn't count on that.) 

 

Friday, September 25, 2026

Thursday, September 24, 2026

The Origins of the War in Ukraine

 Ivan Katchanovski's latest masterpiece book on how the War in Ukraine began is available for free downloads from Springer:

https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-98724-3

The hardcover version is $59.99 on Amazon.

Katchanovski has impeccable academic credentials also indicated by his publication by Springer.  He identifies as Ukrainian and is anti-Putin (unlike me).  He was born in Ukraine, was an active supporter of Ukrainian separation from the Soviet Union, and believes in liberal democracy.*  He was prevented from graduate study in the Soviet Union because his undergraduate thesis concerned Max Weber and western economists.  So instead he got his PhD at George Mason University and held jobs at prestigious locations in US, including Harvard and the Library of Congress, before joining the University of Ottawa where he has become quite famous, most recently for questioning western narratives about the beginning of the War in Ukraine.  His book is the most serious scholarship on the topic.

 *I think it's always been fake, now it's a thin cover for hegemonic fascist imperialism. 

Wednesday, September 23, 2026

Theory and Revolution

 https://liberationschool.org/theory-and-revolution-addressing-the-break-of-ideological-continuity/

The Party for Socialism and Liberation (PSL) released a very insightful essay in 2016 on the importance of defining Socialism in terms of working class power.  Nothing permanent can be achieved until that is done, but rather than using the historical Marxist phrase "smash the bourgeois state," they propose this definition of socialism:

”Socialism is a society where political and economic power is in the hands of the working class and the oppressed. Socialism is a society where the basic needs of the population and the planet are planned for and guaranteed.”

 The key word here is power.  And PSL contrasts this with the proposals of Social Democrats like Bernie Sanders.

PSL recognizes the successful revolution of 1917 that created the Soviet Union, the first of its kind where the working class seized power, and that there is much to learn from the Marxism and Leninism that inspired it.  (PSL uses the phrase "Marxism and Leninism" instead of the typical "Marxism Leninism" that Communist Parties use, but they would also consider themselves communists in essentially that same tradition, which was active in the US from 1919 through the liberation movements of the 1960's, but subsequently snuffed out in the minds of activists and replaced with bourgeois Identity Politics.)



Saturday, September 19, 2026

Limits to Growth vs Paul Ehrlich

Whenever I bring up Limits To Growth, the groundbreaking study based on Systems Dynamics modeling, critics respond about Paul Ehrlich, who made many predictions in his book Population Bomb and in many interviews which were incredibly wrong.  Noah Smith (an economist who I basically despise btw) has a good synopsis:

https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/why-paul-ehrlich-got-everything-wrong

But Paul Ehrlich was not an author of Limits to Growth, and he was not ever a member of the Club of Rome which commissioned it.  

The Club of Rome is still around today making annual report books.  They still say we need to transition to a sustainable society or it will be forced on us at some point in the future, still likely around 2050 (but the exact date is less important than the principle) with Buisness as Usual, with drastic consequences like a large die off of humans, not just demographic shifts.  A sustainable society will not have a growing population and resource use, because the earth is finite.  Our current society can't work like that, resource use growth is forced at every level, especially through the demand for higher profits.  All that seems incontrovertible to me, and it seems we are indeed continuing down the easy road to a catastrophic collapse of several kinds all at once.

Paul Ehrlich's predictions were based on what looks little better than extrapolating current trends.  He predicted catastrophes based on limited resources in the 1970's and 1980's.  These catastrophes never happened, largely because technological changes which at least kicked the can down the road if not solving them completely.

Meanwhile, Limits to Growth made arguments (they denied they were predictions) based on a Systems Dynamics Computer Model of the world called World3.  World3 was run with different scenarios, the Standard scenario represented Business as Usual and showed Growth (of population and material production) peaking in the Middle of the 21st Century.   The authors repeatedly reiterated in interviews that they did not predict catastrophes in the 20th Century, but somehow the confusion with Ehrlich persists.  Another scenario based on wider ecological consciousness, conservation, and reduced materialism showed peaking in the early 22nd Century (but a steeper decline thereafter).

There were several official updates to Limits to Growth, in 1992, 2004, and 2015.  In every update, the authors concluded our actual trajectory still seems closest to the original Standard scenario, which did not even include Global Warming, Endless Wars, and unforced declining Fertility.

Paul Ehrlich was a co-founder of Zero Population Growth (ZPG), which has always advocated for free birth control and abortion on demand, in the US and elsewhere.  I think there are no good arguments against these things, but I know some who make them.  Anyway, ZPG has rebranded itself as Population Connection.  And they are not to be confused with another organization, Negative Population Growth, which has several ideas including severely restricting immigration to USA because immigrants have more children than non-immigrants.  I oppose ideas like that in principle, I believe in as open borders as possible both for economic and fairness reasons.  So awhile after discovering that POV I stopped supporting NPG, but I have been a long time supporter of Population Connection.



Saturday, September 12, 2026

How Many Gazans Killed by Israel

 Tony Hanania (@AntounHananias on X, Antoun Hananias on Medium) says a conservative estimate of the Gazans killed by Israel since 10/7 is 1.2 million, including those buried in rubble.  He points out that Francesca Albanese had estimated 680,000 in 2025.  He is a D.Phil (PhD) and says he is a member of the oldest Palestinian family dating to 1st Century CE, St. Ananias.*

https://medium.com/@antounananias/gaza-genocide-toll-exceeds-aushwitz-91e6405c961c

@MosabAbuToha gives the current count "slaughtered" (by direct gunfire) of 73,787 and estimates the total deaths now exceeds 200,000 (September 12, 2026).

https://x.com/MosabAbuToha/status/2098903369167385017

(*I would think the families of Canaanites and others in the region would go back millenia farther than that, if you accept the name Palestine for the region then, though that name was first applied to the region by Herodotus around 500 BCE, possibly because he was most impressed by the Philistines who had migrated there in the Second Millenium BCE.  But if you want to start when Romans renamed the province which they had previously called Judaea as Syria Palaestina, that was in the 135 CE--the Second Century CE.)


Friday, September 11, 2026

Truth vs antisemitism

 I've been investigating the claims that Israel was behind the assassination of JFK.  I myself firmly believe these claims, for many reasons, including that Israeli whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu confirmed them when he was released from Israeli prison in 2004.  He had been imprisoned for revealing the Israeli nuclear program, how it had been hidden from inspectors in 1964, and revealing that Israel did indeed have nukes--which has been denied both by Israel and the US government ever since--which is pretty amazing, since outside of those two government's denials, everyone else believes it completely, and veteran journalist Seymour Hirsch even wrote a book, The Sampson Option, spelling out the mad way Israel intends to use nukes not merely against threatening Arab nations but against its Western backers, the US and Europe, if they fail to come to Israel's defense when Israel needs it.  That whole book is based on the knowledge, which everyone has, that Israel has nukes.  Epstein friend, liberal Zionist, and highly regarded writer and lecturer Noam Chomsky has also many times presumed the existence of Israeli nukes in exclamations such as "and they have nukes!"  Still, I personally know a Zionist who settled in Israel in the past decade, now lives near Dimona, and continues to deny that Israel has nukes.  These denials are a pretty good indication of who cannot be believed in probably just about anything having to do with geopolitics anyway.

Anyway, the participation of Israel in the JFK assassination has a clear motive because it is very well known now that JFK and the Prime Minister of Israel, David Ben-Gurion, sparred over the US investigating Israel's nuclear program.  The letters they exchanged were long ago declassified and have been published in many places, including most recently by Palestinian American journalist (and now Congressional candidate) Sam Husseini based in Washington DC.  Ben-Gurion insisted that Israeli intentions were peaceful, but because the Israeli nuclear program was assisted by the French, he would not allow for US inspections.  But Kennedy was not backing down.  Kennedy was assassinated a short time later.  Just before that, Ben-Gurion resigned and was replaced with an even more hardline Prime Minister in Israel.  Finally, the US was allowed inspections in 1964 but the US investigators under LBJ were not very thorough, and Mordechi Vanunu later revealed how a fake nuclear control center was constructed to fool the US investigators.  BTW, De Gaulle had also wanted inspections that were being refused by Israel, so Ben-Gurion's claim that he would not allow US inspections because it was a French assisted operation were bogus.  Evidence has subsequently arisen that China was a partner with Israel in nuclear bomb development too.

Now it is curious that one of the first JFK Assassination conspiracy theorists to write a whole book about Israel being involved was Michael Collins Piper, whose first book Final Judgement: The Missing Link in the JFK Assassination Conspiracy was first released in 1994.  It was sometimes banned, but today you can buy the last commemorative edition, from 2015, on Amazon.  It is Piper's most popular book and it went through 5 revisions.  He died unexpectedly of a heart attack in 2015 at the age of 55.  His last and previous editions can be also be obtained online at such places as Wikispooks and the Internet Archive.  Piper renounced copyright to his works.

https://www.amazon.com/Final-Judgment-Missing-Assassination-Conspiracy/dp/1937787370/

https://www.amazon.com/stores/Michael-Collins-Piper/author/B001KCGXU8?ref=ap_rdr&shoppingPortalEnabled=true&ccs_id=278859b5-4a12-4b95-b375-0bd6fb806bf1

https://archive.org/search?query=creator%3A%22Michael+Collins+Piper%22

Piper wrote a review of his own book, which gives a very illuminating summary of the key Mossad connections to many of the key players we have heard about in other theories.  This is like a very brief version of the very long book.

http://jfk-mossad.htmlplanet.com/piper.html

Now it is not at all surprising that Piper is called anti-Semitic and a Holocaust Denier by the likes of ADL and SPLC.  Piper himself said he was not a Holocaust Denier, and more often than not he praises jews such as Seymour Hirsch he says he relied on mostly for his work Final Judgement.  In his more careful writings such as that he clearly distinguishes Jews from Zionists, Israelis, Israeli-supporters, and Neocons.  But he was a prolific writer and and media personality and he was not always that careful.

And while he claimed not to be a Holocaust Denier, he could be categorized as a Holocaust Revisionist.  He wrote a book about the lawsuit of Mel Mermelstein against the Institute of Historical Review, a well known Holocaust revisionist organization that had offered a $50,000 reward to anyone that could prove that gas chambers were used at Auschwitz as part of an industrial scale killing program.  Piper tries to make the case that Mermelstein did not win his case on the merits of the arguments presented but instead on high powered legal tactics.  (That's not entirely implausible, not that I have the least doubt that Auschwitz had an industrial scale killing program that relied on gas chambers.  But the Nazis were pretty good at hiding their secrets.  You may need to combine multiple lines of evidence, including receipts and letters and engineering diagrams, as historians do, to prove the gas chambers.  In contrast, the Zionists boast and broadcast about their crimes.). Ultimately the judge ruled simply that the Holocaust was a fact which could not be denied, and IHR settled with Mermelstein for $90,000.

That book is out of print but is widely available used at mostly inflated prices.  Piper also wrote a book Confessions of an Anti-Semite, another book about the Rothchild banking and global influence operations, and a few others which could be dodgy.  And his books and media were generally printed by a well known self-described "Nationalist" organization (often labeled as White Supremacist) whose backer was one of his best friends.  Though Piper declared himself to be a "Progressive in the La Follette tradition" and he also wrote a book entitled Share the Wealth so he was not at all a traditional conservative.  He died before the rise of MAGA so we can't judge him on MAGA-ness.

In my brief reading of Piper so far I can sense that he is very intelligent and intellectual.  He is not your garden variety dumbass anti-semite.  His error, if there is one, which may be shared with many of the conspiracy writing set, is that he may be blind to items that don't fit the thesis.  This may be intentional or unintentional.  But from what I've read in Piper's JFK work so far, he seems like he may be the best of all in connecting all the dots, as well as critiquing earlier and later theories.  It's not surprising that Final Judgement is highly praised and often touted as the best exposition of a JFK assassination conspiracy theory ever.  And you may also learn quite a bit about the other conspiracy theories and their deniers by reading it.

So, should we discount the theory that Israel was a key player in the JFK assassination because the best known book about it was written by a Holocaust Revisionist and who was at least somewhat anti-semitic?

I don't think so, and I've made the general case in this blog that we can and should judge any ideas and/or writings based on their internal validity and not on the character of the persons who wrote about them.  I've critiqued Noam Chomsky and Norman Finkelstein on this basis, even going so far as to call them Limited Hangouts, but nevertheless saying that we can still learn a great deal from their writings, which are essential reading, while always being aware of their biases (liberal Zionist and anti-China).

In fact, it's hard to find anyone at all that I agree with 100%, so I've quit trying.  The one person I trust the most about Zionism is Tony Greenstein, a jewish socialist anti-Zionist who critiques both Chomsky and Finkelstein as liberal Zionists.  But he can't possibly answer every question we can think of and agrees with me that people must read Finkelstein anyway.

In a similar vein, a more recent proponent of the Israel was a key player in the JFK assassination conspiracy theory is Ryan Dawson.  Not surprisingly, he has also been accused of being both antisemitic and a holocaust denier by the likes of ADL and SPLC. (Unlike with Piper, however, Google AI doesn't offer me a definitive opinion on it.  Dawson has not written books about Holocaust Revisionism or the Rothchilds.) Born in North Carolina and educated at the College of William and Mary, Dawson now lives in Japan as a prolific writer, media personality, and movie producer.  His recent hour and a half documentary NUMEC How Israel Stole the Atomic Bomb and killed JFK looks to be the best of its kind (we could still use better IMO).

https://rumble.com/v1a6xdr-numec-how-israel-stole-the-atomic-bomb.html?e9s=src_v1_upp_pl%2Csrc_v1_pl&playlist_id=QtQvO_cZvSw

Dawson's website is specifically aimed against Neocons, not Jews.  Dawson has appeared on mainstream TV programs and has featured many well known guests on his program, including Finkelstein, it's a quite an impressive list.

https://www.ancreport.com/ 

https://www.ancreport.com/ryan-dawson/


However, one clever Reddit poster clipped a 30 second segment which does make Dawson sound anti-semitic.

https://www.reddit.com/r/VaushV/comments/fxp4hv/everything_you_need_to_know_about_ryan_dawson_in/

Others in that chat repeatedly ask the poster to show the rest of the monologue (which has since been deleted) and claim that Dawson is being taken out of context.  They claim that in the opening Dawson clearly distinguishes between Jews and Zionists, even though that distinction is not being made in these particular 30 seconds.  The original poster refused to show any more of the monologue.

I believe the critics of the poster, that Dawson is being taken out of context in these 30 seconds.  I think he must be starting this section with an additional prelude like this, "It's easy to see how people can become antisemitic when they see so many things, and come to think like this ..."  So he is describing how other people come to think like they do, not that he does.  His inflections seem to reinforce that interpretation, it seems like he is making little of some of the ideas.

I note that the original poster also reveals his biases in statements such as this:

Not like that other quote makes sense. Zionism does not mean Jewish supremacism. Zionism is the belief in the right to self determination for Jews in their homeland. Most countries in the world are based on the same idea, for their respective nations. Something like 90% of Jews are Zionist. It doesn't inherently involve "shooting children". In a parallel universe where the 1947 partition plan is accepted by the arab side Zionism is achieved without any conflict.

He is wrong, Zionism does mean Jewish Supremacism, as it exists today in genocidal apartheid Israel.  Wise jews like Albert Einstein and Hannah Arendt and many others opposed the creation of the State of Israel from the beginning.  The 1947 Partition Plan was neither fair nor agreed to by the inhabitants of Palestine--who ought to have had the last word--nor implemented as written by Israel; Zionists chose to achieve facts on the ground through violence and terror rather than international agreement.  They grabbed all they could and are still doing so.  It was clear from 1898 onwards that Zionists intended to ethnically cleanse all of Palestine by whatever means necessary; they did not intend to stare the land with a rump Palestinian state or with any non-Jews.  Palestine was not ever the one or exclusive homeland of Jews, that would be like calling Germany the homeland of Lutherans.  There were always many other peoples living there, and many if not most Palestinians themselves have descent from First Century BCE Jews who simply changed religions over time.  (Tony Hanania is one example.). 90% of Jews being Zionist (which is wrong on the high side) means little when 90% of US citizens believe in US Exceptionalism.  That Zionists speak like the poster shows that they have become the genocide deniers of our time, and we should take great care in parsing the truth of their statements and agreeing to their claims of antisemitism.  And that even when antisemitism is true, it's only one of many dimensions in which nobody is right about everything.  Zionism can be just as bad, or worse, as antisemitism, and more than 90% of the political and media class in the US is Zionist.  We should denounce, but not necessarily ignore, all of them too even if not antisemitic.  Speaking with an antisemite is not uniquely evil.  

Most people of all ethnicities (not just Jews) are swept away by the political currents and propaganda of their times as well as self interest and approximate thinking.  Jews are not above all the others in these human weaknesses simply because they are Jews.  It just so happened that Zionists got their plan, to the disaster of all, because it aligned with western imperial interests and Zionists still have it, and vast support from Western governments, for the same reason.   

Zionism may even be, as believed by some Jews, among the worst antisemitism of all, since it presumes that all good jews are inherently Zionist (ie, supremacist and genocidal) and regards the others as scum, fake, or self-hating.  The truth is that anti-Zionist Jews are the minority (as it would be among any ethnicity) to buck the currents, propaganda, self-interest, and approximate thinking and see the truth past it.  And our job as anti-Zionists generally is to change those currents and debunk the propaganda.

The Reddit poster also points out how Dawson also blames Israelis for 9/11, on the basis of the widely debunked allegations that Building 7 was blown up with internal bombs.  I don't necessarily accept the bombing allegation, I can accept the official story that fire spread through the elevators.  However, these allegations are not required for the story of Israeli involvement to be possible, or even true.  CIA appears to have been involved in protecting the hijackers from FBI interference, if not actually guiding them.  And it also appears that over and over Al Qaeda has served CIA and Mossad interests, as has ISIS.  Somebodies had to be behind 9/11, and the way the US government failed to stop 9/11 despite many warnings it was going to happen.  Mossad has been at other times shown to work for CIA for deniability purposes, and that would have been useful here.  So while I don't accept that the case has been proven, there are some tantalizing bits of evidence and it's not at all implausible that Mossad was involved.  And thinking about these things does not necessarily embody antisemitism.  After all, the CIA, Bush Administration, and Saudi government are implicated too.  Are we supposed to think that Israel, who had the most to gain, would be above the fray and not involved because they are Jews?

https://thegrayzone.com/2023/04/18/9-11-hijackers-cia-recruits/

Thursday, September 10, 2026

Hong Kong "Democracy" Movement

 Long read on the history and really existing democracy in Hong Kong and it's western backed discontents.

https://theescalatorhk.com/people-of-hong-kong-fight-for-hong-kong-democracy/

A much shorter version is possible and I've given it before, echoing MoonOfAlabama and other sources.  The supposed pro-democracy movement in Hong Kong was a western backed rioting hyper violent Color Revolution, much as has been seen in Afghanistan, Yugoslavia, Libya, Syria, Iran, Xinjiang, Ukraine, and many other places.  It was very violent in Hong Kong, with so-called "protestors" using flame throwers to torch police and innocent bystanders alike.  In Iran recently, hundreds of mosques and other buildings were burned by "protestors" before the Iranian government got control of the situation.  In some places, Color Revolutions succeeded in installing western backed tyranny, in others not.  China has been exceptionally good at repulsing it relatively peaceably.  When you add up all the ways countries are actually controlled, the West is no better than others in implementing the will of the people within resource and other limits, and China probably does it best of all these days.

Friday, September 4, 2026

Ms CIA, the story of Gloria Steinem

 I've made many posts about Gloria Steinem before, from her early (well documented, even admitted) career as CIA funded asset infiltrating spying on and subverting communist youth gatherings, to her middle career as undercover bunny defaming Hugh Hefner at the time Playboy was publishing Seymour Hersh on Mai Lai (Hefner moved to LA and Playboy became non-political after that), founding Ms Magazine to replace class based radical analysis with liberal identity politics--thereby coopting and subverting earlier feminist movements,  demonizing sex workers by promoting very punitive laws against their clients (now the law in Sweden and other places) for which she earned to acronym SWERF, pushing for anti-pornography laws that could hold publishers responsible for any violent crime regardless of whether a connection could be shown (which became law in Sweden, but was resisted in USA, notably by Larry Flynt), defaming Bernie Sanders supporters (as Bernie Bros...despite the fact many were women) in favor of Hillary Clinton in 2016, and promoting an misandric anti-porn and anti-sex ideology which suppressed sexual relations in leftist and liberal movements--thereby tilting reproductive success to the conservative side which ignored her (easily seen in surveys...liberals out-reproduced conservatives up to the 1960's, afterwards and ever since it has been the reverse).  

She may have said a few good things along the way, but such is always the case with controlled opposition and limited hangouts.  

Steinem's version of equality generally didn't mean flattening obscene income and power for everyone, it meant making a place for women at the top of it (this was Ellen Willis analysis of her).  She was pro-Capitalism and pro-Zionism and pro-Imperialism.  While being a claimed Democratic Socialist, and highly revered honorary member of the DSA board in 2009 when I attended the DSA National Convention in 2009, she was later chastised and dethroned from DSA after demonizing Bernie supporters in 2016.

I've felt like I was shouting into a closet until today, when the wraps are off and people with views similar to mine are contributing.  So now you do not need to try to find references to Steinem in the obscure works of radical Pro Sex Feminist Ellen Willis, who started deconstructing Steinem in the 1970's and passed away in the 2006), I can link directly to a pretty good synopsis direct from Redstockings, a radical feminist movement.

https://archive.org/details/001-radical-feminists-wont-be-msled

Steinem admitting her work for CIA and calling CIA liberal and non-violent:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HRUEqyZ7p8&t=10s

An excellent thread on X, with both and many sides represented:

https://x.com/ProudSocialist/status/2095473040779796908

(Some think her work as anti-communism was noble, and that there's no proof she was boosted or connected with CIA later, however the initial funding of Ms Magazine looks interesting as described by Redstockings above.)

Jacobin Magazine weighs in:

https://jacobin.com/2026/09/steinem-feminism-ms-cia-socialism?fbclid=IwY2xjawUIg11wZG9mAWV4dG4DYWVtAjEwAGJyaWQRMTd5TnBkQmIwd2NjeW5hV3ZzcnRjBmFwcF9pZBAyMjIwMzkxNzg4MjAwODkyAAEeP1kHpVpkLV4yvvv3UAuzyo0t-LVmBPYdRXX-JCfs0EY2kpnFQw5pGzayCZI_aem_5R2s65BbUyfaFR428bBodg

Michael Tracey remembers Steinem's vast contribution to the highly destructive allegations regarding ritual satanic abuse of children, which were never proven and now seem to be completely forgotten in the New York Times long and laudatory obituary of Steinem:

https://www.mtracey.net/p/gloria-steinem-leader-of-the-womens