My recent thoughts on the historicity of Jesus have wandered all around much as the Biblical Hebrews...
Until recently, I was willing to believe there was a historical Galilee born itinerant preacher, who gained some following and was ultimately crucified, even if all the miracles and even the resurrection were removed from the story.
Then I became convinced the whole story was a myth, created either by "the Apostle Paul" or even by "James the Brother of Jesus," as at least seven of the key stories about Jesus, starting with the Slaughter of the Innocents, could not have happened without being otherwise known to contemporary non-Christian writers and historians, which they are not (and in fact Jesus does not appear in any contemporary writings that we can confirm, except a couple of brief mentions in the work of Josephus around 90 CE).
I got into a multipart argument with Grok about this today. Grok insisted that a historical Jesus was accepted by the mainstream "historical consensus." Well, as you might imagine, I don't give a damned about a "historical consensus," especially within the West which has virtually been defined by Christianity since 325 CE.
When I claimed that Paul invented the story of Jesus in 62 CE (which is only a minor claim relative to the general historicity of Jesus) Grok responded that the historical consensus was that Paul's letter to the Galatians is believed to have been written 50-60 CE, and that Jesus existence is also established by the Acts of the Apostles and Josephus.
Well, well, the earliest known copy of the Paul's letter to the Galatians is 175-225 CE, the Acts of the Apostles is historically dated to around 100 CE (with the earliest known copies dating to second or third centuries), and Josephus is as reliable as heck.
But now, it appears there is yet another thing. It is even less well established that Paul existed. Unlike Jesus, who gets a couple of brief mentions in Josephus, that do not at least appear to be interpolations (though interpolated elements may have been added to them) Paul gets no mention at all. Outside of Christian writings, Paul gets no mention either in Graeco-Roman history OR in Jewish histories. And someone who did even of the fraction of the things he is said to have done, should have at least gotten some mention. There's no evidence even that early Christian churches received the letters he supposedly wrote.
https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateAChristian/comments/flmac/paul_did_not_exist/
At this point, I throw up my hands. I don't know. And I'm not sure how much it matters, since even if there was a historical Jesus and a historical Paul, the religiously significant things attributed to them could not have happened anyway.
